This is my first attempt at writing, having been inspired by all the great stories and writers here, so I hope readers will be kind…!
A recipe for disaster -- that’s what this was turning out to be. With a yelp of pain he dropped the pan of burnt cookies and dived for the faucet, sighing in relief as the cold cascade of water cooled the burn streak across his fingertips. Even his oven mitts weren’t cooperating, he thought, eyeing the gaping hole in one of them.
His latest baking spree had turned into a weekend long marathon, dotted with one disaster after another. In his estimation, sugar should not look exactly like salt. Accidents were bound to happen and he was sure he wasn't the first person to put a cup of salt into a batch of cookies. And who knew there were so many kinds of sugar anyway? Demerara, yellow, dark brown, fine, confectioner’s, cane…They looked different, felt different and definitely yielded different results when added to a batch of cookie dough. And since when did roll out cookies mean flattening out with a rolling pin, not rolling the dough into a ball? Or why hadn’t his mother warned him that baking soda and baking powder were not interchangeable? And that eggs came in different sizes but recipes didn’t specify which size was called for?
Head spinning, he muttered his exasperation in unflattering terms as he turned off the tap and set about cleaning the kitchen…again. He’d done little else the past two days and he was no closer to finding the perfect recipe, and the contest was this week! Cursing the collective bad luck of the ‘bullpen boys’ as Lucy had dubbed them he took out some of his frustration on the hapless charred remains of what were supposed to be his grandmother’s never-fail hermit cookies. He’d likely have to become a hermit after this fiasco was all over.
“Eleanor Rippendorf!” Her name rolled off his tongue like the vilest of oaths and he took great delight in upending the cookie tray into the garbage. If only Eleanor could be dismissed that easily.
She had cornered their unsuspecting group at a restaurant, just as she had in previous years, catching them unawares as they wolfed down a hasty lunch without the girls for protection. Sue and Lucy had gone to Charlie’s on some errand and Tara had been at an ill-timed dental appointment, which left the men of the team vulnerable to the attack.
Eleanor had swooped in, a chilling combination of coos and trills as she launched into her latest charity project. A celebrity bake off.
“That’s great, Eleanor, but we’re not celebrities,” he had pointed out with a false sense of relief.
“You are to me, fellas,” she’d said as she batted her eyelashes and pursed her lips. He’d known a moment of blind panic when he thought she was going to lean over and kiss him but D had deftly distracted her by lamenting his unavailability due to his married status.
“This time it doesn’t matter, handsome. We’re looking for the best cooks DC has to offer from all walks of life. I’ll put you in our Community Service Worker division. All we need from you is a plate of your very own home baked cookies and the recipe, written out in your own manly script. Our discerning judges…of which I am one… (twitter)…will provide the necessary tastebuds…(she rolled her tongue and poked it out the side of her mouth along with a suggestive wink)…We’ll decide who gets into the semi-finals. The finals take place on the Fourth of July when you’ll head up a hand-picked team to bake your cookies in our outdoor ovens and the public will decide who our top twelve winners will be. They win a page in our…Hunk of the Month calendar…photo and recipe included. All proceeds go to the children’s hospital…How can you say no to that?”
A hearty round of nays had echoed through the restaurant and that was that until the call came from upstairs. In the interest of improving public relations it was deemed beneficial for certain agents to volunteer their services to a charitable cause…
He’d been baking each weekend ever since and had yet to find an edible recipe and now time was running out.
It didn’t help that the other guys in the bullpen actually seemed to be enjoying themselves, either.
Lucy and Tara had suggested that everyone brought in the results of their labours on Monday mornings, and had put up a comments and star ratings board for “The FBI Baking Idol”.
D, on getting their instructions, had asked Donna for help and appropriate recipes, and had produced some excellent milk chocolate chip cookies on the first weekend… and had continued to produce exactly the same cookies each week since then. The (largely) self-appointed judging panel of Lucy, Tara, Sue (and Levi, of course) had dropped hints… followed by increasingly strong suggestions that creativity and variety would be appreciated, all of which had been steadfastly ignored.
Myles and Bobby had, however, got pretty competitive over the last month, and word had spread. The bullpen was getting noticeably crowded every Monday, with the residents of nearby offices oh-so casually ‘just dropping by’ with coffee… and plates.
Scores by the official judges had them neck and neck at the moment, with Myles’ latest offering of white chocolate, apricot and macadamia nut soft cookies just edging out Bobby’s ginger thins, but it was close... and Bobby had been deemed the winner for the previous two weeks.
Then there is my contribution to the baker’s art, thought Jack, mordantly, which seems to be somewhere between a designated public health risk and a level three biohazard. Wiping off the worktop in the kitchen for the fourth time that day, he snorted to himself. Face it, Hudson. You can’t cook. Levi could probably bake better!
He grinned at the mental picture of the golden in an apron and chef’s hat, then, as usual, found his thoughts sliding sideways to the dog’s owner, and sighed.
Sue…
Since she had turned down the New York promotion, he had found it increasingly difficult to keep thinking of her as ‘just’ a friend. Not that she was ‘just’ anything… or ever had been, if he was going to be honest with himself. He had been attracted to her from the moment she stormed into the bullpen, and the feelings had only grown stronger every day since.
Sighing again, he dropped the dishcloth in the sink and put the coffee-maker on.
I have to get past this… stalemate.
Do I tell her how I feel, and risk this job that I love if she does care about me, and her friendship if she doesn’t feel the same?
Or do I carry on as always, stealing looks across the bullpen, pretending that all those lunches and dinners are strictly platonic, afraid to admit how much I want to be with her? Afraid that someone else will come along and I’ll lose her to someone who doesn’t deserve her… not that I deserve her either!
He made the coffee absently, placing the mug on the table to cool a little while he brooded.
She had, of course, offered to help him with this cookery thing when it became evident that his culinary skills were… lacking. Everyone else had laughed as he related his first weekend of baking woes, and although she had smiled, it had been sympathetic.
“I have some great family recipes if you need them, Jack,” she said, softly. Then her eyes began to sparkle with mischief. “and Levi is great at disposing of any cookie related disaster!”
Bobby had waved to get her attention. “D’ya really want to risk poor Levi to Sparky’s cooking?” he grinned. He then spoke directly to the dog lying next to Sue’s desk. “That would probably qualify for hazardous duty, mate. What d’ya think?” Levi groaned and rolled over, covering his nose with his paws, and the bullpen erupted in laughter once again. Jack shot a daggered look at his friend, but Bobby just winked. “Prove me wrong, Sparky!”
Nothing more had been said, but she had smiled again and dropped her hand on to his shoulder briefly before returning to her desk, and he smiled now, remembering the warmth in her eyes.
